Peer-to-peer accommodation markets have been disrupted by the COVID-19 pandemic. However, little attention is paid to how to remedy the disruption in terms of Airbnb business performance. This study empirically investigates the spatially varying COVID-19 disruptions in the Airbnb business and offer place-based remedying strategies through local resources, including tourism clusters and community resilience. Using real data of Airbnb operating performance, COVID-19, and local resources in Florida, we apply geographically weighted regression to estimate the spatial effects in the Airbnb performance model. The results show that Airbnb listings in rural areas that specialized in leisure businesses were more disrupted by COVID-19 than those in urban areas that specialized in hospitality businesses. Furthermore, community resilience attenuated the negative impact of COVID-19 across locations, more in rural areas than in urban areas. These findings enable Airbnb hosts and policymakers to adopt localized resource-based remedying strategies to cope with the pandemic.